Napoleon I (Bonaparte)
The Catholic Encyclopedia, Volume X
by Robert Appleton Company
Emperor of the French, second son of Charles Marie Bonaparte and Maria Lætitia
Ramolino, b. at Ajaccio, in Corsica, 15 August, 1769; d. on the Island of St.
Helena, 5 May, 1821.
His childhood was spent in Corsica; at the end of the year 1778 he entered
the college of Autun, in 1779 the military school of Brienne, and in 1783 the
military school of Paris. In 1785, when he was in garrison at Valence, as a
lieutenant, he occupied his leisure with researches into the history of Corsica
and read many of the philosophers of his time, particularly Rousseau. These
studies left him attached to a sort of Deism, an admirer of the personality of
Christ, a stranger to all religious practices, and breathing defiance against
"sacerdotalism" and "theocracy". His attitude under the
Revolution was that of a citizen devoted to the new ideas, in testimony of which
attitude we have his scolding letter, written in 1790, to Battafuoco, a deputy
from the Corsican noblesse, whom the "patriots" regarded as a
traitor, and also a work published by Bonaparte in 1793, "Le Souper de
Beaucaire", in which he takes the side of the Mountain in the Convention
against the Federalist tendencies of the Girondins.
His military genius revealed itself in December, 1793, when he was twenty
four years of age, in his recapture of Toulon from the English. He was made a
general of brigade in the artillery, 20 December, and in 1794 contributed to
Masséna's victories in Italy. The political suspicions aroused by his
friendship with the younger Robespierre after 9 Thermidor of the Year III (27
July, 1794), the intrigues which led to his being removed from the Italian
frontier and sent to command a brigade against the Vendeans in the west, and ill
health, which he used as a pretext to refuse this post and remain in Paris,
almost brought his career to an end. He contemplated leaving France to take
command of the sultan's artillery. But in 1795 when the Convention was
threatened, Bonaparte was selected for the duty of pouring grapeshot upon its
enemies from the platform of the church of Saint Roch (13 Vendémiaire, Year
IV). He displayed great moderation in his hour of victory, and managed to earn
at once the gratitude of the Convention and the esteem of its enemies.
The Campaign in Italy
On 8 March, 1798, he contracted a civil marriage with the widow of
Alexandre de Beauharnais, Marie Joséphine Rose Tascher de la Pagerie, who was
born in Martinique, in 1763, of a family originally belonging to the
neighbourhood of Blois. In the same month Napoleon set out for Italy, where the
Directory, prompted by Carnot, had appointed him commander in chief against the
First Coalition. The victory of Montenotte, over the Austrians commanded by
Beaulieu, and those of Millesimo, Dego, Ceva, and Mondovi, over Colle's
Piedmontese troops, forced Victor Amadeus, King of Sardinia, to conclude the
armistice of Cherasco (28 April, 1796). Wishing to effect a junction on the
Danube with the Army of the Rhine, Bonaparte spent the following May in driving
Beaulieu across Northern Italy, and succeeded in pushing him back into the
Tyrol. On 7 May he was ordered by the Directory to leave half of his troops in
Lombardy, under Kellermann's command, and march with the other half against
Leghorn, Rome, and Naples. Unwilling to share the glory with Kellermann,
Bonaparte replied by tendering his resignation, and the order was not insisted
on. In a proclamation to his soldiers (20 May, 1796) he declared his intention
of leading them to the banks of the Tiber to chastise those who had
"whetted the daggers of civil war in France" and "basely
assassinated" Basseville, the French minister, to "re-establish the
Capitol, place there in honor the statues of heroes who had made themselves
famous", and to "arouse the Roman people benumbed by many centuries of
bondage". In June he entered the Romagna, appeared at Bologna and Ferrara,
and made prisoners of several prelates. The Court of Rome demanded an armistice,
and Bonaparte, who was far from eager for this war against the Holy See, granted
it. The Peace of Bologna (23 June, 1796) obliged the Holy See to give up Bologna
and Ferrara to French occupation, to pay twenty one million francs, to surrender
100 pictures, 500 manuscripts, and the busts of Junius and Marcus Brutus. The
Directory thought these terms too easy, and when a prelate was sent to Paris to
negotiate the treaty, he was told that as an indispensable condition of peace,
Pius VI must revoke the Briefs relating to the Civil Constitution of the clergy
and to the Inquisition. The Pope refused, and negotiations were broken off; they
failed again at Florence, where an attempt had been made to renew them.
During these pourparlers between Paris and Rome, Bonaparte repulsed
the repeated efforts of the Austrian Wurmser to reconquer Lombardy. Between 1
and 5 August, Wurmser was twice beaten at Lonato and again at Castiglione;
between 8 and 15 September, the battles of Roveredo, Primolano, Bassano, and San
Giorgio forced Wurmser to take refuge in Mantua, and on 16 October Bonaparte
created the Cispadan Republic at the expense of the Duchy of Modena and of the
Legations, which were pontifical territory. Then, 24 October, he invited Cacault,
the French minister at Rome, to reopen negotiations with Pius VI "so as
to catch the old fox"; but on 28 October he wrote to the same Cacault:
"You may assure the pope that I have always been opposed to the treaty
which the Directory has offered him, and above all to the manner of negotiating
it. I am more ambitious to be called the preserver than the destroyer of the
Holy See. If they will be sensible at Rome, we will profit by it to give peace
to that beautiful part of the world and to calm the conscientious fears of many
people." Meanwhile the arrival in Venetia of the Austrian troops under
Alvinzi caused Cardinal Busca, the pope's secretary of State, to hasten the
conclusion of an alliance between the Holy See and the Court of Vienna; of this
Bonaparte learned through intercepted letters. His victories at Arcoli (17
November, 1796) and Rivoli (14 January, 1797) and the capitulation of Mantua (2
February, 1797), placed the whole of Northern Italy in his hands, and in the
spring of 1797 the Pontifical States were at his mercy.
The Directory sent him ferocious instructions. "The Roman
religion", they wrote, "will always be the irreconcilable enemy of the
Republic; first by its essence, and next, because its servants and ministers
will never forgive the blows which the Republic has aimed at the fortune and
standing of some, and the prejudices and habits of others. The Directory
requests you to do all that you deem possible, without rekindling the torch of
fanaticism, to destroy the papal Government, either by putting Rome under some
other power or" which would be still better "by establishing some form
of self government which would render the yoke of the priests odious." But
at the very moment when Bonaparte received these instructions he knew, by his
private correspondence, that a Catholic awakening was beginning in France.
Clarke wrote to him: "We have become once more Roman Catholic in
France", and explained to him that the help of the pope might perhaps be
needed before long to bring the priests in France to accept the state of things
resulting from the Revolution. Considerations such as these must have made an
impression on a statesman like Bonaparte, who, moreover, at about this period,
said to the parish priests of Milan: "A society without religion is like a
ship without a compass; there is no good morality without religion." And in
February, 1797, when he entered the Pontifical States with his troops, he
forbade any insult to religion, and showed kindness to the priests and the
monks, even to the French ecclesiastics who had taken refuge in papal territory,
and whom he might have caused to be shot as émigrés. He contented himself with
levying a great many contributions, and laying hands on the treasury of the
Santa Casa at Loretto. The first advances of Pius VI to his "dear son
General Bonaparte" were met by Bonaparte's declaring that he was ready to
treat. "I am treating with this rabble of priests [cette prêtraille],
and for this once Saint Peter will again save the Capitol", he wrote to
Joubert, 17 February, 1797. The Peace of Tolentino was negotiated on 19
February; the Holy See surrendered the Legations of Bologna, Ferrara, and
Ravenna, and recognized the annexation of Avignon and the Comtat Venaissin by
France. But Bonaparte had taken care not to infringe upon the spiritual power,
and had not demanded of Pius VI the withdrawal of those Briefs which were
offensive to the Directory. As soon as the treaty was signed he wrote to Pius VI
to express to him "his perfect esteem and veneration"; on the other
hand, feeling that the Directory would be displeased, he wrote to it: "My
opinion is that Rome, once deprived of Bologna, Ferrara, the Romagna, and the
thirty millions we are taking from her, can no longer exist. The old machine
will go to pieces of itself." And he proposed that the Directory should
take the necessary steps with the pope in regard to the religious situation in
France.
Then, with breathless rapidity, turning back towards the Alps, and
assisted by Joubert, Masséna, and Bernadotte, he inflicted on Archduke Charles
a series of defeats which forced Austria to sign the preliminaries of Leoben (18
April, 1797). In May he transformed Genoa into the Ligurian Republic; in October
he imposed on the archduke the Treaty of Campo Formio, by which France obtained
Belgium, the Rhine country with Mainz, and the Ionian Islands, while Venice was
made subject to Austria. The Directory found fault with this last stipulation;
but Bonaparte had already reached the point where he could act with independence
and care little for what the politicians at Paris might think. It was the same
with his religious policy: he now began to think of invoking the pope's
assistance to restore peace in France. A note which he addressed to the Court of
Rome, 3 August, 1797, was conceived in these terms: "The pope will perhaps
think it worthy of his wisdom, of the most holy of religions, to execute a Bull
or ordinance commanding priests to preach obedience to the Government, and to do
all in their power to strengthen the established constitution. After the first
step, it would be useful to know what others could be taken to reconcile the
constitutional priests with the non constitutional."
While Bonaparte was expressing himself thus, the Councils of the Five
Hundred and the Ancients were passing a law to recall, amnesty, and restore to
their civil and political rights the priests who had refused to take the oath of
the Civil Constitution of the Clergy. But Directors Barrès, Rewbell, and
Lareveillère Lépeaux, considering that this act jeopardized the Republic,
employed General Augereau, Bonaparte's lieutenant, to carry out the coup d'état
of 18 Fructidor against the Councils (4 Sept., 1797), and France was once more a
prey to a Jacobin and anti-Catholic policy. These events were immediately echoed
at Rome, where Joseph Bonaparte, the general's brother, and ambassador from the
Directory, was asked by the latter, to favour the Revolutionary party.
Disturbances arose: General Duphot was killed in Joseph Bonaparte's house (28
December, 1797), and the Directory demanded satisfaction from the Holy See.
General Bonaparte had just returned to Paris, where he apparently confined
himself to his functions as a member of the Institute (Scientific Section). He
was by no means anxious to lead the expedition against Rome, which the Directory
was projecting, and contented himself with giving Berthier, who commanded it,
certain instructions from a distance. For this expedition for Berthier's entry
into Rome and the proclamation of the Roman Republic (10-15 February, 1798), and
for the captivity of Pius VI, who was carried off a prisoner to Valence,
The Campaign in Egypt
While in Paris, Bonaparte induced the Directory to take up the plan of an
expedition to Egypt. His object was to make the Mediterranean a French lake, by
the conquest of Malta and the Nile Valley, and to menace England in the
direction of India. He embarked on 19 May, 1798. The taking of Malta (10 June),
of Alexandria (2 July), the battle of the Pyramids (21 July), gave Bonaparte the
uncontested mastery of Cairo. At Cairo he affected a great respect for Islam;
reproached with this later on, he replied: "It was necessary for General
Bonaparte to know the principles of Islamism, the government, the opinions of
the four sects, and their relations with Constantinople and Mecca. It was
necessary, indeed, for him to be thoroughly acquainted with both religions, for
it helped him to win the affection of the clergy in Italy and of the ulemas in
Egypt."
The French troops in Egypt were in great danger when the naval disaster of
Aboukir, inflicted by Nelson, had cut them off from Europe. Turkey took sides
with England: in the spring of 1799, Bonaparte made a campaign in Syria to
strike both Turkey and England. Failing to effect the surrender of Acre, and as
his army was suffering from the plague (May, 1799), he had to make his way back
to Egypt. There he re-established French prestige by the victory of Aboukir (25
July, 1799), then, learning that the Second Coalition was gaining immense
successes against the armies of the Directory, he left Kléber in Egypt and
returned secretly to France. He landed at Fréjus, 9 October, 1799, and was in
Paris seven days later. Besides certain political results, the expedition to
Egypt had borne fruit for science: Egyptology dates its existence from the
creation of the Institute of Egypt (Institut d'Egypte) by Bonaparte.
Bonaparte, First Consul
While Bonaparte was in Egypt, the religious policy of the Directory had
provoked serious troubles in France. Deportations of priests were multiplying;
Belgium, where 6000 priests were proscribed, was disturbed; the Vendée,
Normandy, and the departments of the South were rising. France was angry and
uneasy. Spurred on by his brother Lucien, president of the Five Hundred, allied
with Directors Sieyès and Roger Ducos, Bonaparte caused Directors Gohier and
Moulins to be imprisoned, and broke up the Five Hundred (18 Brumaire; 9-10
November, 1799). The Directorial Constitution was suppressed, and France
thenceforward was ruled by three consuls. First Consul Bonaparte put into
operation the Constitution known as that of the Year VIII, substituted for the
departmental administrators elected by the citizens, others appointed by the
Executive Power, and reorganized the judicial and financial administrations. He
commissioned the Abbé Bernier to quiet the religious disturbance of the
Vendeans, and authorized the return of the non juring priests to France on
condition of their simply promising fidelity to the laws of the republic. Then,
to make an end of the Second Coalition, he entrusted the Army of Germany to
Moreau, and, himself taking command of the Army of Italy, crossed the Great St.
Bernard (13-16 May, 1800) and, with the co operation of Desaix, who was mortally
wounded, crushed the Austrians (14 June, 1800) between Marengo and San Giuliano
at the very spot he had marked on the map in his study in the Tuileries. The
Peace of Lunéville, concluded with Austria, 9 February, 1801, extended the
territory of France to 102 departments.
Bonaparte spent the years 1801 and 1802 effecting internal reforms in
France. A commission, established in 1800, elaborated a new code which, as the
"Code Napoléon", was to be promulgated in 1804, to formally introduce
some of the "principles of 1789" into French law, and thus to complete
the civil results of the Revolution. But it was Napoleon's desire that, in the
new society which was the issue of the Revolution, the Church should have a
place, and consciences should be set at rest. The Concordat with the Holy See
was signed on 17 July, 1801; it was published, together with the Organic
Articles, as a law, 16 April, 1802. The former of these two acts established the
existence of the Church in France, while the other involved the possibility of
serious interference by the State in the life of the Church. Napoleon never
said, "The Concordat was the great fault of my reign." On the
contrary, years afterwards, at St. Helena, he considered it his greatest
achievement, and congratulated himself upon having, by the signature of the
Concordat, "raised the fallen altars, put a stop to disorders, obliged the
faithful to pray for the Republic, dissipated the scruples of those who had
acquired the national domains, and broken the last thread by which the old
dynasty maintained communication with the country." Fox, in a conversation
with Napoleon at this period, expressed astonishment at his not having insisted
upon the marriage of priests: "I had, and still have, to accomplish
peace", Napoleon replied, "theological controversies are allayed with
water, not with oil." The Concordat had wrecked the hopes of those who,
like Mme de Staël, had wished to make Protestantism the state religion of
France; and yet the Calvinist Jaucourt, defending the Organic Articles before
the Tribunat, gloried in the definitive recognition of the Calvinist religion by
the state. The Jewish religion was not recognized until later (17 March, 1808),
after the assembly of a certain number of Jewish delegates appointed by the
prefects (29 July, 1806) and the meeting of the Great Sanhedrim (10 February —
9 April, 1807); the State, however, did not make itself responsible for the
salaries of the rabbis. Thus did the new master of France regulate the religious
situation in that country.
On 9 April, 1802, Caprara was received for the first time by Bonaparte in
the official capacity of Pius VI's legate a latere, and before the first
consul took an oath which, according to the text subsequently published by the
"Moniteur", bound him to observe the constitution, the laws, statutes,
and customs of the republic, and nowise to derogate from the rights, liberties,
and privileges of the Gallican Church. This was a painful surprise for the
Vatican, and Caprara declared that the words about Gallican liberties had been
interpolated in the "Moniteur". Another painful impression was
produced at the Vatican by the attitude of eight constitutional priests whom
Bonaparte had nominated to bishoprics, and to whom Caprara had granted canonical
institution, and who afterwards boasted that they had never formally abjured
their adhesion to the Civil Constitution of the clergy. In retaliation, the
Roman curia demanded of the constitutional parish priests a formal retractation
of the Civil Constitution, but Bonaparte opposed this and when Caprara insisted,
declared that if Rome pushed matters too far the consuls would yield to the
desire of France to become Protestant. Talleyrand spoke to Caprara in the same
sense, and the legate desisted from his demands. On the other hand, though
Bonaparte had at first been extremely irritated by the allocution of 24 May,
1802, in which Pius VI demanded the revision of the Organic Articles, he ended
by allowing it to be published in the "Moniteur" as a diplomatic
document. A spirit of conciliation on both sides tended to promote more cordial
relations between the two powers. The proclamation of Bonaparte as consul for
life (August, 1802) increased in him the sense of his responsibility towards the
religion of the country, and in Pius VI the desire to be on good terms with a
personage who was advancing with such long strides towards omnipotence.
Bonaparte took care to gain the attachment of the revived Church by his
favours. While he dissolved the associations of the Fathers of the Faith, the
Adorers of Jesus, and the Panarists, which looked to him like attempts to
restore the Society of Jesus, he permitted the reconstitution of the Sisters of
Charity, the Sisters of St. Thomas, the Sisters of St. Charles, and the
Vatelotte Sisters, devoted to teaching and hospital work, and made his mother,
Madame Lætitia Bonaparte, protectress of all the congregations of hospital
sisters. He favoured the revival of the Institute of the Christian Schools for
the religious instruction of boys; side by side with the lycées, he
permitted secondary schools under the supervision of the prefects, but directed
by ecclesiastics. He did not rest content with a mere strict fulfilment of the
pecuniary obligations to the Church to which the Concordat had bound the State;
in 1803 and 1804 it became the custom to pay stipends to canons and desservants
of succursal parishes. Orders were issued to leave the Church in possession of
the ecclesiastical buildings not included in the new circumscription of
parishes. Though the State had not bound itself to endow diocesan seminaries,
Bonaparte granted the bishops national estates for the use of such seminaries
and the right to receive donations and legacies for their benefit; he even
founded, in 1804, at the expense of the State, ten metropolitan seminaries,
re-established, with a government endowment, the Lazarist house for the
education of missionaries, and placed the Holy Sepulchre and the Oriental
Christians under the protection of France.
As to the temporal power of the popes Bonaparte at this period affected a
somewhat complaisant attitude towards the Holy See. He restored Pesaro and
Ancona to the pope, and brought about the restitution of Benevento and
Pontecorvo by the Court of Naples. After April, 1803, Cacault was replaced, as
his representative at Rome, by one of the five French ecclesiastics to whom Pius VI
had consented to grant the purple late in 1802. This ambassador was no other
than Bonaparte's own uncle, Cardinal Joseph Fesch, whose secretary for a short
time was Chateaubriand, recently made famous by his "La génie du
Christianisme". One of Bonaparte's grievances against Cacault was a saying
attributed to the latter: "How many sources of his glory would cease if
Bonaparte ever chose to play Henry VIII!" Even in those days of harmony
Cacault had a presentiment that the Napoleonic policy would yet threaten the
dignity of the Holy See.
The idea of a struggle with England became more and more an imperious
obsession of Bonaparte's mind. The Peace of Amiens (25 March, 1802) was only a
truce: it was broken on 22 May, 1803, by Mortier's invasion of Hanover and the
landing of the English in French Guiana. Napoleon forthwith prepared for his
gigantic effort to lay the ban of Europe on England. The Duc d'Enghien, who was
suspected of complicity with England and the French Royalists, was carried off
from Ettenheim, a village within the territory of Baden, and shot at Vincennes,
21 March, 1804, and one of Cardinal Fesch's first acts as ambassador at Rome was
to demand the extradition of the French émigré Vernègues, who was in
the service of Russia, and whom Bonaparte regarded as a conspirator.
NAPOLEON EMPEROR
The Coronation
While the Third Coalition was forming between England and Russia,
Bonaparte caused himself to be proclaimed hereditary emperor (30 April 18 May,
1804), and at once surrounded himself with a brilliant Court. He created two
princes imperial (his brothers Joseph and Louis), seven permanent high
dignitaries, twenty great officers, four of them ordinary marshals, and ten
marshals in active service, a number of posts at Court open to members of the
old nobility. Even before his formal proclamation as emperor, he had given
Caprara a hint of his desire to be crowned by the pope, not at Reims, like the
ancient kings, but at Notre Dame de Paris. On 10 May, 1804, Caprara warned Pius VI
of this wish, and represented that it would be necessary to answer yes, in order
to retain Napoleon's friendship. But the execution of the Duc d'Enghien had
produced a deplorable impression in Europe; Royalist influences were at work
against Bonaparte at the Vatican, and the pope was warned against crowning an
emperor who, by the Constitution of 1804, would promise to maintain "the
laws of the Concordat", in other words, the Organic Articles. Pius VI and
Consalvi tried to gain time by dilatory replies, but these very replies were
interpreted by Fesch at Rome, and by Caprara at Paris, in a sense favourable to
the emperor's wishes. At the end of June, Napoleon I joyfully announced, at the
Tuileries, that the pope had promised to come to Paris. Then Pius VI tried to
obtain certain religious and political advantages in exchange for the journey he
was asked to make. Napoleon declared that he would have no conditions dictated
to him; at the same time he promised to give new proofs of his respect and love
for religion, and to listen to what the pope might have to submit. At last the
cleverness of Talleyrand, Napoleon's minister of foreign affairs, conquered the
scruples of Pius VI; he declared, at the end of September, that he would accept
Napoleon's invitation if it were officially addressed to him; he asked only that
the ceremony of consecration should not be distinct from the coronation proper,
and that Napoleon would undertake not to detain him in France. Napoleon had the
invitation conveyed to Pius VI, not by two bishops, as the pope expected, but by
a general; and before setting out for France, Pius VI signed a conditional act
of abdication, which the cardinals were to publish in case Napoleon should
prevent his returning to Rome; then he began his journey to France, 2 November,
1804.
Napoleon would not accord any solemn reception to Pius VI; surrounded by a
hunting party, he met the pope in the open country, made him get into the
imperial carriage, seating himself on the right, and in this fashion took him to
Fontainebleau. Pius VI was brought to Paris by night. The whole affair nearly
fell through at the last moment. Pius VI informed Josephine herself, on the eve
of the day set for the coronation of the empress, that she had not been married
to Napoleon in accordance with the rules of religion. To the great annoyance of
the emperor, who was already contemplating a divorce, in case no heir were born
to him, and was displaying a lively irritation against Josephine, Pius VI
insisted upon the religious benediction of the marriage; otherwise, there was to
be no coronation. The religious marriage ceremony was secretly performed at the
Tuileries, on the first of December, without witnesses, not during the night,
but at about four o'clock in the afternoon, by Fesch, grand almoner of the
imperial household. As Welschinger has proved, Fesch had previously asked the
pope for the necessary dispensations and faculties, and the marriage was
canonically beyond reproach. On 2 December the coronation took place. Napoleon
arrived at Notre Dame later than the hour appointed. Instead of allowing the
pope to crown him, he himself placed the crown on his own head and crowned the
empress, but, out of respect for the pope, this detail was not recorded in the
"Moniteur". Pius VI, to whom Napoleon granted but few opportunities
for conversation, had a long memoranda drawn up by Antonelli and Caprara,
setting forth his wishes; he demanded that Catholicism should be recognized in
France as the dominant religion; that the divorce law should be repealed; that
the religious communities should be re-established; that the Legations should be
restored to the Holy See. Most of these demands were to no purpose: the most
important of the very moderate concessions made by the emperor was his promise
to substitute the Gregorian Calendar for that of the Revolution after 1 January,
1806. When Pius VI left Paris, 4 April, 1805, he was displeased with the
emperor.
But the Church of France acclaimed the emperor. He was lauded to the skies
by the bishops. The parish priests, not only in obedience to instructions, but
also out of patriotism, preached against England, and exhorted their hearers to
submit to the conscription. The splendour of the Napoleonic victories seemed, by
the enthusiasm with which it inspired all Frenchmen, to blind the Catholics of
France to Napoleon's false view of the manner in which their Church should be
governed. He had reorganized it; he had accorded it more liberal pecuniary
advantages than the Concordat had bound him to; but he intended to dominate it.
For example, in 1806 he insisted that all periodical publications of a religious
character should be consolidated into one, the "Journal des curés",
published under police surveillance. On 15 August, 1806, he instituted the Feast
of St. Napoleon, to commemorate the martyr Neopolis, or Neopolas, who suffered
in Egypt under Diocletian. In 1806 he decided that ecclesiastical positions of
importance, such as cures of souls of the first class, could be given only to
candidates who held degrees conferred by the university, adding that these
degrees might be refused to those who were notorious for their
"ultramontane ideas or ideas dangerous to authority". He demanded the
publication of a single catechism for the whole empire, in which catechism he
was called "the image of God upon earth," "the Lord's
anointed", and the use of which was made compulsory by a decree dated 4
April, 1806. The prisons of Vincennes, Fenestrelles, and the Island of Sainte
Marguerite received priests whom the emperor judged guilty of disobedience to
his orders.
The Great Victories; Occupation of Rome; Imprisonment of Pius VI
(1805-09).
After 1805 relations between Pius VI and Napoleon became strained. At
Milan, 26 May, 1805, when Napoleon, as King of Italy, took the Iron Crown of
Lombardy, he was offended because the pope did not take part in the ceremony.
When he asked Pius VI to annul the marriage which his brother Jerome Bonaparte
had contracted, at the age of nineteen with Elizabeth Patterson of Baltimore,
the pope replied that the decrees of the Council of Trent against clandestine
marriages applied only where they had been recognized, and the reply constituted
one more cause of displeasure for the emperor, who afterwards, in 1806, obtained
an annulment from the complaisant ecclesiastical authorities of Paris. And when
Consalvi, in 1805, complained that the French Civil Code, and with it the
divorce law, had been introduced into Italy, Napoleon formally refused to make
any concession.
The great war which the emperor was just then commencing was destined to
be an occasion of conflict with the Holy See. Abandoning the preparations which
he had made for an invasion of England (the Camp of Boulogne), he turned against
Austria, brought about the capitulation of Ulm (20 October, 1805), made himself
master of Vienna (13 November), defeated at Austerlitz (2 December, 1805)
Emperor Francis I and Tsar Alexander. The Treaty of Presburg (26 December, 1805)
united Dalmatia to the French Empire and the territory of Venice to the Kingdom
of Italy, made Bavaria and Wurtemberg vassal kingdoms of Napoleon, enlarged the
margravate of Baden, and transformed it into a grand duchy, and reduced Austria
to the valley of the Danube. The victory of Trafalgar (21 October, 1805) had
given England the mastery of the seas, but from that time forward Napoleon was
held to be the absolute master of the Continent. He then turned to the pope, and
demanded a reckoning of him.
To prevent a landing Russian and English troops in Italy, Napoleon, in
October, 1805, had ordered Gouvion Saint Cyr to occupy the papal city of Ancona.
The pope, lest the powers hostile to Napoleon might some day reproach him with
having consented to the employment of a city of the Pontifical States as a base
of operations, had protested against this arbitrary exercise of power: he had
complained, in a letter to the emperor (13 November, 1805), of this "cruel
affront", declared that since his return from Paris he had
"experienced nothing but bitterness and sorrow", and threatened to
dismiss the French ambassador.
But the treaty of Presburg and the dethronement of the Bourbons of Naples
by Joseph Bonaparte and Masséna (January, 1806), changed the European and the
Italian situation. From Munich Napoleon wrote two letters (7 January, 1806), one
to Pius VI, and the other to Fesch, touching his intentions in regard to the
Holy See. He complained of the pope's ill will, tried to justify the occupation
of Ancona, and declared himself the true protector of the Holy See. "I will
be the friend of Your Holiness", he concluded, "whenever you consult
only your own heart and the true friends of religion." His letter to Fesch
was much more violent: he complained of the refusal to annul Jerome's marriage,
demanded that there should no longer be any minister either of Sardinia or of
Russia in Rome, threatened to send a Protestant as his ambassador to the pope,
to appoint a senator to command in Rome and to reduce the pope to the status of
mere Bishop of Rome, claimed that the pope should treat him like Charlemagne,
and assailed "the pontifical camarilla which prostituted religion". A
reply from Pius VI (29 January, 1806), asking for the return of Ancona and the
Legations let loose Napoleon's fury. In a letter to Pius VI (13 February), he
declared: "Your Holiness is the sovereign of Rome but I am its emperor; all
my enemies ought to be yours"; he insisted that the pope should drive
English, Russian, Sardinian, and Swedish subjects out of his dominions, and
close his ports to the ships of those powers with which France was at war; and
he complained of the slowness of the Curia in granting canonical institution to
bishops in France and Italy. In a letter to Fesch he declared that, unless the
pope acquiesced he would reduce the condition of the Holy See to what it had
been before Charlemagne.
An official note from Fesch to Consalvi (2 March, 1806) defined Napoleon's
demands; the cardinals were in flavor of rejecting them, and Pius VI, in a very
beautiful letter, dated 21 March, 1806, remonstrated with Napoleon, declared
that the pope had no right to embroil himself with the other states, and must
hold aloof from the war; also, that there was no emperor of Rome. "If our
words", he concluded, "fail to touch Your Majesty's heart we will
suffer with a resignation conformable to the Gospel, we will accept every kind
of calamity as coming from God." Napoleon, more and more irritated,
reproached Pius VI for having consulted the cardinals before answering him,
declared that all his relations with the Holy See should thenceforward be
conducted through Talleyrand, ordered the latter to reiterate the demands which
the pope had just rejected, and replaced Fesch as ambassador at Rome with
Alquier, a former member of the Convention. Then the emperor proceeded from
words to deeds. On 6 May, 1806, he caused Cività Vecchia to be occupied.
Learning that the pope, before recognizing Joseph Bonaparte as King of Naples,
wished Joseph to submit to the ancient suzerainty of the Holy See over the
Neapolitan Kingdom, he talked of "the spirit of light headedness" (esprit
de vertige) which prevailed at Rome, remarked that, when the pope thus
treated a Bonaparte as a vassal, he must be tired of wielding the temporal
power, and directed Talleyrand to tell Pius VI that the time was past when the
pope disposed of crowns. Talleyrand was informed (16 May, 1806) that, if Pius VI
would not recognize Joseph, Napoleon would no longer recognize Pius VI as a
temporal prince. "If this continues", Napoleon went on to say, "I
will have Consalvi taken away from Rome." He suspected Consalvi of having
sold himself to the English. Early in June, 1806, he seized Benevento and
Pontecorvo, two principalities which belonged to the Holy See, but which were
shut in by the Kingdom of Naples.
Yielding before the emperor's wrath, Consalvi resigned his office: Pius VI
unwillingly accepted his resignation, and replaced him with Cardinal Casoni. But
the first dispatch written by Casoni under Pius VI's dictation confirmed the
pope's resistance to the emperor's behests. Napoleon then violently
apostrophized Caprara, in the presence of the whole court, threatening to
dismember the Pontifical States, if Pius VI did not at once, "without
ambiguity or reservation", declare himself his ally (1 July, 1806). A like
ultimatum was delivered, on 8 July, to Cardinal Casoni by Alquier. But
Continental affairs were claiming Napoleon's attention, and the only immediate
result of his ultimatum was the emperor's order to his generals occupying Ancona
and Cività Vecchia, to seize the pontifical revenues in those two cities. On
the other hand, the constitution of the Imperial University (May, 1806),
preparing for a state monopoly of teaching, loomed up as a peril to the Church's
right of teaching, and gave the Holy See another cause for uneasiness.
The Confederation of the Rhine, formed by Napoleon out of fourteen German
States (12 July, 1806), and his assertion of a protectorate over the same,
resulted in Francis II's abdication of the title of emperor of Germany; it its
place Francis took the title of emperor of Austria. Thus ended, under the blows
dealt it by Napoleon, that Holy Roman Germanic Empire which had exerted so great
an influence over Christianity in the Middle Ages. The pope and the German
emperor had long been considered as sharing between them the government of the
world in the name of God. Napoleon had definitively annihilated one of these
"two halves of God", as Victor Hugo has termed them. Frederick William
II of Prussia became alarmed, and in October, 1806, formed, with England and
Russia, the Fourth Coalition. The stunning victories of Auerstädt, won by
Davoust, and Jena, won by Napoleon (14 October, 1806), were followed by the
entry of the French into Berlin, the king of Prussia's flight to Königsberg,
and the erection of the Electorate of Saxony into a kingdom in alliance with
Napoleon. From Berlin itself Napoleon launched a decree (21 November, 1806) by
which he organized the Continental blockade against England, aiming to close the
whole Continent against English commerce. Then, in 1807, penetrating into
Russia, he induced the tsar by means of the battles of Eylau (8 February, 1807)
and Friedland (14 June, 1807), to sign the Peace of Tilsit (8 July, 1807). The
empire was at its apogee; Prussia had been bereft of its Polish provinces, given
to the King of Saxony under the name of the Grand Duchy of Warsaw; the Kingdom
of Westphalia was being formed for Jerome Bonaparte, completing the series of
kingdoms given since 1806 to the emperor's brothers — Naples having been
assigned to Joseph, and Holland to Louis. A series of principalities and
duchies, "great fiefs", created all over Europe for his marshals,
augmented the might and prestige of the empire. At home, the emperor's personal
power was becoming more and more firmly established; the supervision of the
press more rigorous; summary incarcerations more frequent. He created an
hereditary nobility as an ornament to the throne.
To him it was something of a humiliation, that the Court of Rome persisted
in holding aloof, politically, from the great conflicts of the nations. He began
to summon the pope anew. He had already, soon after Jena, called Mgr Arezzo to
him from Saxony, and in menacing fashion had bidden him go and demand of Pius VI
that he should become the ally of the empire; once more Pius VI had replied to
Arezzo that the pope could not consider the enemies of France his enemies.
Napoleon also accused the pope of hindering the ecclesiastical reorganization of
Germany, and of not making provision for the dioceses of Venetia. His grievances
were multiplying. On 22 July, 1807, he wrote to Prince Eugène, who governed
Milan as his viceroy, a letter intended to be shown to the pope: "There
were kings before there were popes", it ran. "Any pope who denounced
me to Christendom would cease to be pope in my eyes; I would look upon him as
Antichrist. I would cut my peoples off from all communication with Rome. Does
the pope take me for Louis the Pious? What the Court of Rome seeks is the
disorder of the Church, not the good of religion. I will not fear to gather the
Gallican, Italian, German and Polish Churches in a council to transact my
business [pour faire mes affaires] without any pope, and protect my
peoples against the priests of Rome. This is the last time that I will enter
into any discussion with the Roman priest rabble [la prêtraille romaine]".
On 9 August Napoleon wrote again to Prince Eugène, that, if the pope did
anything imprudent, it would afford excellent grounds for taking the Roman
States away from him. Pius VI, driven to bay, sent Cardinal Litta to Paris to
treat with Napoleon: the pope was willing to join the Continental blockade, and
suspend all intercourse with the English, but not to declare war against them.
The pope even wrote to Napoleon (11 September, 1807) inviting him to come to
Rome. The emperor, however, was only seeking occasion for a rupture, while the
pope was seeking the last possible means of pacification.
Napoleon refused to treat with Cardinal Litta, and demanded that Pius VI
should be represented by a Frenchman, Cardinal de Bayanne. Then he pretended
that Bayanne's powers from the pope were not sufficient. And while the pope was
negotiating with him in good faith, Napoleon, without warning, caused the four
pontifical Provinces of Macerata, Spoleto, Urbino, and Foligno to be occupied by
General Lemarrois (October, 1807). Pius VI then revoked Cardinal Bayanne's
powers. It as evident that, not only did Napoleon require of him an offensive
alliance against England, but that the Emperor's pretensions, and those of his
new minister of foreign affairs, Champagny, Talleyrand's successor, were now
beginning to encroach upon the domain of religion. Napoleon claimed that one
third of the cardinals should belong to the French Empire; and Champagny let it
be understood that the emperor would soon demand that the Holy see should
respect the "Gallican Liberties", and should abstain from "any
act containing positive clauses or reservations calculated to alarm consciences
and spread divisions in His Majesty's dominions". Henceforth it was the
spiritual authority that Napoleon aspired to control. Pius VI ordered Bayanne to
reject the imperial demands. Napoleon then (January, 1808) decided that Prince
Eugène and King Joseph should place troops at the disposition of General
Miollis, who was ordered to march on Rome. Miollis at first pretended to be
covering the rear of the Neapolitan army, then he suddenly threw 10,000 troops
into Rome (2 February). Napoleon wrote to Champagny that it was necessary
"to accustom the people of Rome and the French troops to live side by side,
so that, should the Court of Rome continue to act in an insensate way, it might
insensibly cease to exist as a temporal power, without anyone noticing the
change". Thus it may be said that, in the beginning of 1808, Napoleon's
plan was to keep Rome.
In a manifesto to the Christian powers, Pius VI protested against this
invasion; at the same time, he consented to receive General Miollis and treated
him with great courtesy. Champagny, on 3 February, again insisted on the pope's
becoming the political ally of Napoleon, and Pius VI refused. The instructions
given to Miollis became more severe every day: he seized printing presses,
journals, post offices; he decimated the Sacred College by having seven
cardinals conducted to the frontier, because Napoleon accused them of dealing
with the Bourbons of the two Sicilies, then, one month later, he expelled
fourteen other cardinals from Rome because they were not native subjects of the
pope. Cardinal Doria Pamphili, who had been appointed secretary of state, in
February, 1808, was also expelled by Miollis; Pius VI now had with him only
twenty one cardinals, and the papal Government was disorganized. He broke off
all diplomatic relations with Napoleon, recalled Bayanne and Caprara from Paris,
and uttered his protest in a consistorial allocution delivered in March.
Napoleon, on his side, recalled Alquier from Rome. The struggle between pope and
emperor was taking on a tragic character.
On 2 April Napoleon signed two decrees: one annexed to the Kingdom of
Italy "in perpetuity" the Provinces of Urbino, Ancona, Macerata, and
Camerino; the other ordered all functionaries of the Court of Rome who were
natives of the Kingdom of Italy to return to that kingdom, under pain of
confiscation of their property. Pius VI protested before all Europe against this
decree, on 19 May, and, in an instruction addressed to the bishops of the
provinces which Napoleon was lopping off from his possessions, he denounced the
religious "indifferentism" of the imperial Government, and forbade the
faithful of those provinces to take the oath of allegiance to Napoleon or accept
any offices from him. Miollis retaliated, 12 June, by driving Gavrielli, the new
secretary of state, out of Rome. Pius VI then replaced Gavrielli with Cardinal
Pacca, reputed an opponent of France; on 11 July he delivered a very spirited
allocution, which, in spite of the imperial police, was circulated throughout
Europe; and Pacca, on 24 August, directed a note against the institution of the
"Civic Guard" — an idea recently conceived by Miollis — in which
Miollis was compelling even the pope's soldiers to enroll. On 6 September, 1808,
Miollis sent two officers to the Quirinal to arrest Pacca; Pius VI interposed,
declaring that they should not arrest Pacca without arresting the pope, and that
in future the secretary of state should sleep at the Quirinal, which was closed
to all the French.
The definitive execution of Napoleon's projects against the Holy See was
retarded by the wars which occupied him during the year 1808. When he
transferred his brother Joseph from the Throne of Naples to that of Spain, Spain
rose, and the English invaded Portugal. Dupont's capitulation, at Baylen (20
July, 1808), and Junot's at Cintra (30 August, 1808), were painful reverses for
French arms. Napoleon, having made an alliance with the tsar in the celebrated
interview of Erfurt (27 September — 14 October, 1808), hastened to Spain.
There he found a people whose spirit of resistance was exasperated all the more
because they believed themselves to be fighting for their liberty and the
integrity of their faith as much as for their country. In November he gained the
victories of Burgos, Espinosa, Tudela, and Somo Sierra, and reopened the gates
of Madrid for Joseph; on 21 February Saragossa was taken by the French armies
after an heroic resistance. A Fifth Coalition was formed against Napoleon: he
returned from Spain and, rushing across Bavaria, bombarded and took Vienna (11
13 May, 1809). On the day after the victory he devoted some of his leisure hours
to thinking about the pope.
For some time Murat, who in 1808 had replaced Joseph as King of Naples,
had been ready to support Miollis whenever Napoleon should judge that the hour
had come to incorporate Rome with the empire. On 17 May, 1809, Napoleon issued
from Schönbrunn two decrees in which, reproaching the popes for the ill use
they had made of the donation of Charlemagne, his "august
predecessor", he declared the Pontifical States annexed to the empire, and
organized, under Miollis, a council extraordinary to administer them. On 10 June
Miollis had the Pontifical flag, which still floated over the castle of St.
Angelo, lowered. Pius VI replied by having Rome placarded with a Bull
excommunicating Napoleon. When the emperor received news of this (20 June) he
wrote to Murat: "So the pope has aimed an excommunication against me. No
more half measures; he is a raving lunatic who must be confined. Have Cardinal
Pacca and other adherents of the pope arrested." In the night of 5 6 July,
1809, Radet, a general of gendarmerie, by the orders of Miollis, entered the
Quirinal, arrested Pius VI and Pacca, gave them two hours to make their
preparations, and took them away from Rome at four in the morning. Pius VI was
taken to Savona, Pacca to Fenestrella. Meanwhile Napoleon, completing the work
of crushing Austria, had been the victor at Essling (21 May, 1809) and at Wagram
(6 July, 1809), and the Peace of Vienna (15 October, 1809) put the finishing
touch to the mutilation of Austria by handing over Carniola, Croatia, and Friuli
to France, at the same time obliging the Emperor Francis to recognize Joseph as
King of Spain. The young german, Staps, who attempted to assassinate Napoleon at
Schöenbrunn (13 October), died crying: "Long live Germany!"
Discussion with the captive Pius VI; Second Marriage; Ecclesiastical
Councils of 1809 and 1811.
The conflict with his prisoner, the pope, was another embarrassment, a new
source of anxiety to the emperor. At first he took all possible steps to prevent
the public from hearing of what had happened at Rome: the "Moniteur"
made not the slightest allusion to it; the newspapers received orders to be
silent. He also wished his excommunication to be ignored; the newspapers must be
silent on this point also; but the Bull of Excommunication, secretly brought to
Lyons, was circulated in France by members of the Congregation, a pious
association, founded 2 February, 1801, by Père Delpuits, a former Jesuit.
Alexis de Noailles and five other members of the Congregation were arrested by
the emperor's command, and his anger extended to all the religious orders. He
wrote (12 September, 1809) to Bigot de Préameneu, minister of public worship:
"If on 1 October there are any missions or congregations still in France, I
will hold you responsible." The celebrated Abbé Frayssinous had to
discontinue his sermons; the Lazarists dispersed; the Sulpicians were
threatened. Napoleon consulted Bigot de Préameneu as to the expediency of
laying the Bull before the Council of State, but abstained from doing so.
It was not long, however, before he had to face an enormous difficulty:
there were more than twenty bishoprics vacant, and Pius VI declared to Fesch, to
Caprara, and to Maury that, so long as he was a prisoner, so long as he could
not communicate freely with his natural counselors, the cardinals, he would not
provide for the institution of the bishops. Thus the life of the Church of
France was partially suspended. In November, 1809, Napoleon appointed an
"ecclesiastical council" to seek a solution of the difficulty. With
Fesch as president, this council included as members Cardinal Maury, Barral,
Archbishop of Tours, Duvoisin, Bishop of Nantes, Emery, Superior of S. Sulpice,
Bishops Canaveri of Vercelli, Bourlier of Evreux, Mannay of Trèves, and the
Barnabite Fontana. Bigot de Préameneu, in the name of the emperor, laid before
the council several sets of questions relating to the affairs of Christendom in
general, then to those of France, and lastly to those of Germany and Italy, and
to the Bull of Excommunication.
In the preamble to its replies, the council gave voice to a petition for
the absolute liberty of the pope and the recall of the cardinals. It declared
that if a general council were assembled for the settlement of the religious
questions then pending, the pope's presence at the council would be necessary,
and that a national council would not have sufficient authority in questions
affecting the whole Catholic Church. It also declared that the pope could not
complain of any essential violation of the Concordat, that, when he advanced his
temporal spoliation, as one reason for his refusal to institute the bishops
canonically, he was confounding the temporal order with the spiritual, that the
temporal sovereignty was only an accessory of the papal authority, that the
invasion of Rome was not a violation of the Concordat, and that the national
council would interpose an appeal from the Bull of Excommunication either to the
general council or to the pope better informed. The manner in which canonical
institution might be secured for the bishops, if the pope should continue his
resistance, was twice discussed. Urged by the Government, the council admitted
that, taking the circumstances into consideration, the conciliary institution
given by a metropolitan to his suffragans, or by the senior suffragan to a new
metropolitan, might possibly be recognized by a national council as,
provisionally, a substitute for pontifical Bulls. Emery, thinking the council
too lenient, refused to endorse the answers, which were sent to Napoleon on 11
January, 1810.
On 17 February, 1810, the Act regulating the Roman territory and future
condition of the pope, introduced by Régnault de Saint Jean d'Angély, was
passed unanimously by the senate. The Papal States, in accordance with this
decree, were to form two departments; from Rome, which was declared the first
city of the empire, the prince imperial was to take his title of king. The
emperor, already crowned once at Notre Dame, was to go within ten years to be
crowned at St. Peter's. The pope was to have a revenue of two millions. The
empire was to charge itself with the maintenance of the Sacred Congregation of
Propaganda. The pope, on his accession, must promise to do nothing contrary to
the four articles of the Gallican Church. Another Act of the Senate, of 25
February, 1810, made the Declaration of 1682 a general law of the empire. Thus
did Napoleon flatter himself that he would reduce the papacy to servitude and
bring Pius VI to live in Paris. He even prepared a letter to Pius VI in
which he told him: "I hold in execration the principles of the Bonifaces
and the Gregorys. It is my mission to govern the West; do not meddle with
it." This letter he would have had taken to the pope by bishops who were to
give notice to Pius VI that in future the popes must swear allegiance to
Napoleon, as of yore to Charlemagne, and to inform him that he himself would be
dispensed from this obligation, but that he must undertake not to reside at
Rome. Napoleon expected in this way to bend the pope to his will. Wiser
counsellors, however, prevailed upon him not to send this insulting letter.
Nevertheless, to carry out his plan of removing the papal throne from Rome, he
ordered Miollis to compel all the cardinals who were still at Rome to set out
for Paris, and to have the Vatican archives transported thither. In 1810 there
were twenty seven Roman cardinals in Paris; he lavished gifts upon them, invited
them to the court festivals, and wished them to write and urge Pius VI to yield;
but, following the advice of Consalvi, the cardinals refused.
It was in the midst of these bitter conflicts with the church that,
Napoleon desiring an heir, resolved to divorce Josephine. Ever since the end of
1807 Metternich had been aware of the reports that were current about the
emperor's approaching divorce. On 12 December, 1807, Lucien Bonaparte had vainly
endeavored to obtain from Josephine her consent to this divorce; some time
after, Fouché had made a similar attempt with no better success. In December,
1809, at Fontainebleau, in the presence of Prince Eugène, Josephine's son, the
emperor induced her to consent; on 15 December, this was solemnly proclaimed in
the throne room, in the presence of the Court, in an address delivered by
Napoleon, and another read by the unhappy Josephine, who was prevented by her
tears from finishing it. The Act of the Senate (16 December), based on a report
of Lacépède, the naturalist, himself a member of the Senate, ratified the
divorce. Napoleon then thought of marrying the tsar's sister. But Metternich,
getting wind of this project, made Laborde and Schwarzenberg sound the Tuileries
to see if Napoleon would marry an Austrian archduchess. The idea pleased
Napoleon. The Court of Vienna, however, first required that the spiritual bond
between Napoleon and Josephine should be severed.
This bond the pope alone was competent to dissolve; Louis XII had had
recourse to Alexander VI; Henry IV to Clement VIII; but Napoleon, excommunicated
by his prisoner Pius VI, could not apply to him. Cambacérès, the arch
chancellor, sent for the diocesan officials of Paris and explained to them that
the marriage of Napoleon and Josephine had been invalid in consequence of the
absence of the parish priest of the two parties and of witnesses. In vain did
they object that only the pope could decide such a case; they were told to
commence proceedings, and be quick about it. On 26 December, the promoter of the
case, Rudemare, begged Cambacérès to submit the matter to the ecclesiastical
council over which Fesch presided. On 2 January, 1810, Cambacérès sent a
request to the official, Boislesve, for a declaration of nullity of the
marriage, alleging, this time, that there had been absence of consent on
Napoleon's part. On the next day the ecclesiastical council replied that if the
defect of Napoleon's consent could be proved to the officiality, the marriage
would be null and void. Cambacérès wished to produce Fesch, Talleyrand, Duroc,
and Berthier as witnesses. The testimony of Fesch was very confused; he
explained that the pope had given him the necessary dispensations to bless the
marriage; that two days later he had given Josephine a marriage certificate;
that the emperor had then upbraided him, declaring to him that he (the emperor)
had only agreed to this marriage in order to quiet the empress, and that it was,
moreover, impossible for him to renounce his hopes of direct descendants. The
other two witnesses told how Napoleon had repeatedly expressed the conviction
that he was not bound by this marriage and that he regarded the ceremony only as
"a mere concession to circumstances [acte de pure circonstance]
which ought not to have any effect in the future".
On 9 January the diocesan authorities declared the marriage null and void,
on the ground of the absence of the lawful parish priest and of witnesses; it
pronounced this decision only in view of the "difficulty in the way of
having recourse to the visible head of the Church, to whom it has always
belonged in fact to pronounce upon these extraordinary cases." The promoter
Rudemare had concluded with the recommendation that the tribunal should at least
lay a precept upon the two parties to repair the defect of form which had
vitiated their marriage; Boilesve, the official, refrained from proffering this
invitation. Rudemare then appealed to the metropolitan authorities on this
point. On 12 January, 1810, the official, Lejeas, with much greater
complaisance, admitted both the grounds of nullity advanced by Cambacérès —
that is, not only the defect of form, but also the defect of the emperor's
consent. He alleged that the civil marriage of Napoleon and Josephine had been
annulled by the decree of the Senate, that by the concordatory laws (lois
concordataires) the religious marriage ought to follow the civil, and that
the Church could not now ask two parties who were no longer civilly married to
repair the defects of form in their religious marriage. Thus, he declared, the
marriage was religiously annulled. It may be noted here that the Catholic Church
cannot be held responsible for the excessive complaisance shown in this matter
by the ecclesiastical council and the diocesan authorities of Paris. On 21
January, 1810, Napoleon resolved to ask for the hand of Marie Louise. The French
ambassador at Vienna, at the request of the Archbishop of Vienna, gave him his
word of honour that the sentence pronounced by the diocesan authorities of Paris
was legal. At last all the religious obstacles to the celebration of the new
marriage were disposed of.
It took place on 1 April, 1810, but thirteen of the cardinals then in
Paris refused to be present. These thirteen cardinals were turned away when they
presented themselves at the Tuileries two days later; the minister of public
worship informed them that they were no longer cardinals, that they no longer
had any right to wear the purple; the minister of police forwarded them, two by
two, to small country towns; their pensions were suppressed, their property
sequestrated. People called them "the black cardinals". The bishops
and priests of the Roman States were treated with similar violence; nineteen out
of thirty two bishops refused the oath of allegiance to the emperor, and were
imprisoned, while a certain number of non juring parochial clergy were interned
in Corsica, and the emperor announced his intention of reducing the number of
dioceses and parishes in the Roman States by three fourths. This policy of
bitter persecution coincided with fresh overtures to his prisoner, the pope,
through the Austrian diplomat Lebzeltern (May, 1810). Pius VI's reply was that,
to negotiate, he must be free and able to communicate with the cardinals. In
July Napoleon sent Cardinals Spina and Caselli to Savona, but they obtained
nothing from the pope. There had been no solution of the internal crisis of the
Church of France; while Pius VI was a prisoner the bishops were not to receive
canonical institution. Bigot de Préameneu and Maury suggested to the emperor a
possible arrangement; to invite the chapter in each diocese to designate the
bishop who had been nominated, but not yet canonically instituted, provisional
administrator. Fesch refused to lend himself to this expedient and occupy the
Archbishopric of Paris; but a certain number of nominated bishops did go to
their episcopal cities in the capacity of provisional administrators. Going one
step further, Napoleon removed Maury from the See of Montefiascone, and d'Osmond
from that of Nancy, and had them designated by the respective chapters
provisional administrators of the two vacant Archdioceses of Paris and Florence.
Maury and d'Osmond, at the emperor's bidding, left the dioceses given them by
the pope to install themselves in these archdioceses.
Unauthorized Site:
This site and its contents are not affiliated, connected,
associated with or authorized by the individual, family,
friends, or trademarked entities utilizing any part or
the subject's entire name. Any official or affiliated
sites that are related to this subject will be hyper
linked below upon submission
and Evisum, Inc. review.
Please join us in our mission to incorporate The Congressional Evolution of the United States of America discovery-based curriculum into the classroom of every primary and secondary school in the United States of America by July 2, 2026, the nation’s 250th birthday. , the United States of America: We The
People. Click Here